• Zodiac Necklace

Early on, she asked about your star sign — and well, the rest is history. With this dainty necklace, she’ll show off just how proud she is to be an ambitious Capricorn or sensitive Cancer.

• “What I Love About You” Journal

Fill this book with sweet nothings, inside jokes, and future plans. If you want to focus more on your relationship as a whole, check out the similar What I Love About Us book.

• Handwriting Bracelet

You’ve exchanged “I love yous” 1,000 times, but what if you could say it on a bracelet … in your actual handwriting? Now that’s romantic. Hit up this Etsy shop owner and she’ll make one for you in 18K gold, rose gold, or sterling silver.

• “The Start of Us” Map

Take it back to the beginning with this custom map print that shows what the night sky looked like at the exact moment in the location that you first locked eyes, kissed, or fell in love. Choose from a standard print, canvas, or framed poster.

• Personalized Folded Book Art

If you’re in love with a book lover, it doesn’t get more thoughtful than this. Etsy shop Caleb Adams Art will take your initials and carve them into a stunning Valentine’s Day gift (it also makes an excellent fifth anniversary gift!).

• “What a Difference a Day Makes” Burlap Print

One way to celebrate Valentine’s Day is to look back at the days that mattered most in your relationship — when you met, got married, and the birth dates of your kids. This Etsy shop owner makes beautiful artwork of them all (and provides you with a way to remember that anniversary date!).

• 100 Movies Scratch Off Poster

This poster will inspire you both to watch some of the most beloved Hollywood films, including Dirty Dancing, Mean Girls, and more.

• Date Night In: More than 120 Recipes to Nourish Your Relationship

The way to her heart is through her stomach, which means that this totally sweet (and seriously delicious) cookbook is a must. Because homemade Dulce de Leche is the glue in your relationship, isn’t it?

• XO Sterling Silver Stud Earrings

These handmade earrings go with pretty much any outfit — and the sweet “XO” sentiment lets everyone know that they’re from someone special (you!).

• Our Moments Couples: 100 Thought Provoking Conversation Starters for Great Relationships

No couple wants to be that couple, sitting at a restaurant in silence because they’ve run out of things to talk about. This sweet gift of 100 meaningful conversation starters is something you both can enjoy before, during, or after a night out. It’s also a great idea if you have a road trip coming up!